Are Wild Westerns Rubbish? Red Dead Redemption Screens

Conversation in the SPOnG office this morning ranged from whether the follow-up to Michael Bay's Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen should be called Transformers: Revenge of the Audience or whether it was an okay movie to why Wild Western movies are always rubbish (one voice of disagreement sounded there).

Can the same be said for video games - aside from Boot Hill? Maybe looking at all these screens from Red Dead Redemption will help you decide... look at them, now.