French Culture Mininster - 'Games Have Great Cultural Value'
A backdoor way of justifying tax-breaks for French games firms?
The French culture minister has declared that home-grown videogames should be recognized as a cultural industry eligible for tax breaks.
This would give the industry the same recognition as French cinema, which received state financial support equivalent to €523 million, or £350 million, in 2004.
Renaud Donnedieu de Vabres told The International Herald Tribune to, “Call me the minister of video games if you want - I am proud of this… People have looked down on video games for far too long, overlooking their great creativity and cultural value."
He added, "Video games are not a mere commercial product. They are a form of artistic expression involving creation from script writers, designers and directors."
This follows the news from earlier this year that Nintendo's gaming mini-god, Shigeru Miyamoto and a number of other leading games designers were awarded the Ordre des Arts et des Lettres in recognition of their cultural accomplishments.
Cynics however, might point to the fact that some of the major players in France’s videogame industry have been facing tough times of late: Infogrames constantly battling with debt problems; Ubisoft being part-owned by Electronic Arts; Vivendi relying perhaps a little too heavily on revenue from World Of Warcraft.
A Brussels-based group called The Interactive Software Federation of Europe, has spoken out against possible tax breaks for French games companies. Patrice Chazerand, secretary general of the ISFE noted, "The French concept of culture is that the government knows better than consumers. It is unhealthy to have the French government using discriminatory subsidies to influence video games."
Gerhard Florin, executive vice president for international publishing at Electronic Arts, added, "Similar to what happened with the French film industry, these plans will prove bad for the industry and for consumers. French cinema's financial assistance supports only a few well-connected producers who no longer need to pay attention to consumers."
This would give the industry the same recognition as French cinema, which received state financial support equivalent to €523 million, or £350 million, in 2004.
Renaud Donnedieu de Vabres told The International Herald Tribune to, “Call me the minister of video games if you want - I am proud of this… People have looked down on video games for far too long, overlooking their great creativity and cultural value."
He added, "Video games are not a mere commercial product. They are a form of artistic expression involving creation from script writers, designers and directors."
This follows the news from earlier this year that Nintendo's gaming mini-god, Shigeru Miyamoto and a number of other leading games designers were awarded the Ordre des Arts et des Lettres in recognition of their cultural accomplishments.
Cynics however, might point to the fact that some of the major players in France’s videogame industry have been facing tough times of late: Infogrames constantly battling with debt problems; Ubisoft being part-owned by Electronic Arts; Vivendi relying perhaps a little too heavily on revenue from World Of Warcraft.
A Brussels-based group called The Interactive Software Federation of Europe, has spoken out against possible tax breaks for French games companies. Patrice Chazerand, secretary general of the ISFE noted, "The French concept of culture is that the government knows better than consumers. It is unhealthy to have the French government using discriminatory subsidies to influence video games."
Gerhard Florin, executive vice president for international publishing at Electronic Arts, added, "Similar to what happened with the French film industry, these plans will prove bad for the industry and for consumers. French cinema's financial assistance supports only a few well-connected producers who no longer need to pay attention to consumers."
Read More Like This
Comments
SPInGSPOnG 6 Nov 2006 12:37
1/5
If it's tax breaks that give us awesome French cinema, as opposed to tedious Hollywood drivel, then Vivre le Tax Break.
RiseFromYourGrave 6 Nov 2006 15:19
2/5
its all very good news to hear the frogs trying to raise the general opinion of videogames.
but -
ubisoft are part owned by EA??
but -
ubisoft are part owned by EA??
more comments below our sponsor's message
gashead 6 Nov 2006 15:40
3/5
RiseFromYourGrave wrote:
ubisoft are part owned by EA??
19.9% owned in fact - from 2004.
OptimusP 6 Nov 2006 18:40
4/5
Someone get Luc Besson to make a game... a TAXI game! SOMEONE!! FOR THE LOVE OF GOD!
RiseFromYourGrave 7 Nov 2006 01:38
5/5
gashead wrote:
19.9% owned in fact - from 2004.
good grief, so what's all this 'EA are going down' s**te that ubisoft have been spouting recently? and why did none of the articles i read on such hollow rubbish mention the partial ownership of ubisoft by EA?