As Gawkers' Kotaku points out about the Game Critics Awards list, which it and 28 other sources have worked up, "Lots of sites and magazines will tell you what they thought the best stuff at E3 was. Heck, we did! But only one set of awards are the result of the biggest outlets joining forces."
Big, as we know is best and most informative (hence mainstream media is so much more informative and successful right now than the blogosphere). So, this is in fact, "the definitive list of what really stole the show at E3." So, now you know. The nice thing is also that all of the big names in gaming get a mention.
Best of ShowUncharted 2: Among ThievesNaughty Dog/Sony Computer Entertainment America for PlayStation 3
Best Original GameScribblenauts5TH Cell/Warner Bros Interactive Entertainment for Nintendo DS
Best Console GameUncharted 2: Among ThievesNaughty Dog/Sony Computer Entertainment America for PlayStation 3
Best PC GameStar Wars: The Old RepublicBioWare Austin/LucasArts
Best Handheld GameScribblenauts5TH Cell/Warner Bros Interactive Entertainment for Nintendo DS
Best Hardware/Peripheral"Project Natal"Microsoft for Xbox 360
Best Action GameModern Warfare 2Infinity Ward/Activision for PlayStation 3, Xbox 360, PC
Best Action/Adventure GameUncharted 2: Among ThievesNaughty Dog/Sony Computer Entertainment America for PlayStation 3
Best Role Playing GameMass Effect 2BioWare/Electronic Arts for Xbox 360, PC
Best Racing GameSplit/SecondBlack Rock/Disney Interactive Studios for PlayStation 3, Xbox 360, PC
Best Sports GameFight Night Round 4EA Canada/EA Sports for PlayStation 3, Xbox 360
Best Fighting GameTatsunoko vs. Capcom: Ultimate All-StarsEighting/Capcom for Nintendo Wii
Best Strategy GameSupreme Commander 2Gas Powered Games/Square-Enix for Xbox 360, PC
Best Social/Casual/PuzzleDJ HeroFreestyle/Red Octane/Activision for PlayStation 3, Xbox 360, Wii
Best Online MultiplayerLeft 4 Dead 2Valve/EAP for Xbox 360, PC
The source of this bigness.