US Mag States: Don't Buy Wii Fit

It's too much work.

Posted by Staff
US Mag States: Don't Buy Wii Fit
A Forbes article entitled 'The Truth About Wii Fit And Weight Loss' that certainly mentions Wii Fit but contains nothing about weight loss, advises consumers simply not to buy the game.

Shigeru Miyamoto has already stated that he doesn't, "think Wii Fit’s purpose is to make you fit; what it’s actually aiming to do is make you aware of your body".

The author of the piece goes further, Bonnie Ruberg, saying, "Still, it seems a little disingenuous for Nintendo to heavily market a fitness tool that's sitting in more than a million American living rooms collecting dust."

She is joined in her dismissal of the title by Brian Crecente of Kotaku. His take is even more brutal - although it casts a poor light into the health regimes of video games journalists. He states, "I have to keep reminding people, even though it's a videogame, it's still exercise. It might be fun a little bit, but it's work."

There is, however, some actual information buried in the piece. Apparently "Scott Owens, a professor of exercise science at the University of Mississippi, has started a six-month study to uncover whether placing Wii Fit in a home will actually improve a family's physical fitness."

We'll keep up with that.

Finally, the premise of the article - rather than being about 'the truth' of weight loss - is that people buy the game and then never use it. Have you bought Wii Fit? Do you still use it? Tell us in the Forum.

Games:

Comments

Nom de plumage 30 Jan 2009 12:44
1/17
I bought a Wii and never use it.
OptimusP 30 Jan 2009 12:50
2/17
So the article says that Wiifit won't get you in shape if you don't use it...wauw...really?

I thaught just buying a stairmaster gets me in shape with no effort at all...

I'm trowing in the "yanks are consuming idiots" argument with this one.
more comments below our sponsor's message
iceman 30 Jan 2009 12:57
3/17
I bought a wii fit and after using it I had a fit and so was disqualified from driving for a year. In the meantime I used wii fit daily and have suffered no more fits, however I have gained 3 stone
LORI611 30 Jan 2009 13:02
4/17
I got WII Fit for Christmas and I LOVE it!! It's fun and it gets me moving. That is saying alot in these dark depths of winter!
wiiman 30 Jan 2009 13:13
5/17
I hardly ever bother with it, but my girlfriend is on it everyday. her balance has improved amazingly and her flexibility. Obviously its no mirracle cure, you're still going to have to do some other healthy living to really shift weight.
alex 30 Jan 2009 13:13
6/17
anything that gets kids up and around doing something instead of sitting there doing nothing is great in my book. Why do people only attack something if it is a sucess. If the Wii Fit had flopped, it would never have been attacked like it always seems to be. Why cant these people get over the fact they have no good ideas and instead of belittleing everything that over people do, try and do something worth while.
Donna 30 Jan 2009 13:47
7/17
I have the WII FIT and use it daily - I love it
bambi 30 Jan 2009 13:54
8/17
I buy Fit, and try it a few months, then ask guy to date, but guy say I'm not fit.
I can't get a refund.
neil 30 Jan 2009 14:04
9/17
I've bought all sorts of games and never played them. I've also bought a gym membership and not used it. I've also bought games and used them, and I've bought gym memberdhips and not used them.
Anon 30 Jan 2009 14:09
10/17
I bought a 12 month gym membership and never used it, does that mean you can't loose weight in a gym?
Grammar we love you 30 Jan 2009 14:43
11/17
bambi wrote:
I buy Fit, and try it a few months, then ask guy to date, but guy say I'm not fit.
I can't get a refund.


Post a picture and let us all decide!
JJ 30 Jan 2009 15:02
12/17
We bought one and the wife still uses it, Plus its great with various outher games like Rayman Rabbid Rabbids tv
Me 30 Jan 2009 16:06
13/17
Face it, Yanks are fat and stupid, so won't know how to use a Wii Fit
Grammar we love you 30 Jan 2009 16:32
14/17
Me wrote:
Face it, Yanks are fat and stupid, so won't know how to use a Wii Fit


Yeah. Not like the Poms, eh?



and

markj 30 Jan 2009 17:09
15/17
well, yes, i bought the wii fit, and yes it's now just collecting dust in my cabinet, worst is, even my wii console is also gathering dust. it was just fun for the first 2 months. i'm just planning to sell the whole set i have right now.
JC 3 Feb 2009 22:13
16/17
We have the WII fit and love it. I don't depend on it solely for exercise but we find the games great fun especially like the balance games and we are moving instead of sitting and watching TV. But you have to use it to get any benefit. Just like a treadmill, if you don't use it then you get no benefit from it.
CC 9 Feb 2009 18:50
17/17
I've had my Wii Fit for 10 days and have used it every day for 30 to 60 minutes per day. I expect some people do purchase a Wii Fit and never use it - just as I once joined a gym and never went. Does that mean I should tell people not to join gyms? That would be silly. Obviously, if you're pretty sure you won't use something, don't buy it - but I've already used my Wii Fit more than I used my gym membership.
Posting of new comments is now locked for this page.