Golden Joysticks Little More Than Bad Joke Circle Jerk

Awards fail to even make sense.

Posted by Staff
Golden Joysticks Little More Than Bad Joke Circle Jerk
The UK games industry furthered the suspicion that it comprises little more than a set of self-serving marketing execs as the ‘results’ of last Friday’s Golden Joysticks ceremony are dissected.

Here are the awards and respective winners:

PlayStation 2 Game of the Year - Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
GameCube Game of the Year - Resident Evil 4
Xbox Game of the Year - Halo 2
PC Game of the Year - Half Life 2
Carphone Warehouse Handheld Game of the Year - Super Mario 64 DS
Best Film-Based Game of 2005 - Resident Evil 4
BBC Radio One - Colin and Edith's Best Game Soundtrack of 2005 - Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
The Sun Online - Online Game of the Year - World of Warcraft
Publisher of the Year - Nintendo
Retailer of the Year - Play.com
The Game One Gaming Innovation of the Year - PSP
The One to Watch for Xmas - The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
The Sun's One to Watch for 2006 - Resident Evil 5
Hero of 2005 - CJ from Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
Villain of 2005 - Officer Tenpenny from Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
The Girl's Choice for 2005 - The Sims 2
Editor's Game of the Year - Resident Evil 4
Unsung Hero of the Year - Fahrenheit
Nuts Magazine's Ultimate Game of 2005 - Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas


A few points. We’re told that The One to Watch for this Christmas is Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess from Nintendo. We found this interesting, given that Zelda isn’t expected to hit retail until the summer of next year in any territory.

There’s more. We’re told that the one to watch for 2006 is Resident Evil 5, a game about which nothing is known.

Next is an award so brilliantly stupid we can’t think of anything to write about it. Best Film-Based Game of 2005 - Resident Evil 4. Genius.

The rest comprises a list of things that sold well (as voted for by the kids who decide these matters) and things that people have heard of, as not voted for by the aforementioned kids. Given that about half the awards are not the result of a public vote, we found the BBC’s blanket statement interesting “The awards are voted for by the readers of computer and games magazines.”

Ignoring the undeniable fact that the awards represent little more than an embarrassing self-parody, Future wheeled out head of 'Filling Microsoft Marketing Pamphlets' James Ashton-Tyler, who used to go by the name of James Ashton. Perhaps he got married, perhaps he became ‘a bit pretentious’. It's not for us to say. "We're very excited about what happened this year " he said. You see, some of the time reading Xbox press releases, talking about how exciting everything is, has worn off. You go, James! "Not only was the event bigger than ever, but the number of voters who took part showed how much the Golden Joysticks means to real gamers. The night was a real celebration of the best on offer from the UK gaming industry as a whole."

Or the exact opposite of that...

Let us know your thoughts in the forum below.
Companies:

Comments

bunny goes squish 7 Nov 2005 11:17
1/8
Pssst.. SPOnG needs new glasses...
The one to watch for 2006 is listed as Resident Evil *5*, not 4.
Not that that makes much more sense...
ann0uk 7 Nov 2005 11:44
2/8
The Game One Gaming Innovation of the Year - PSP
What innovation does the PSP offer? and dont mention that it plays movies and music, What does it do for gaming?. I own a PSP and I think it is a cool piece of kit but it is not innovative, it is just a portable PS2.
more comments below our sponsor's message
TigerUppercut 7 Nov 2005 11:52
3/8
bunny goes squish wrote:
Pssst.. SPOnG needs new glasses...
The one to watch for 2006 is listed as Resident Evil *5*, not 4.
Not that that makes much more sense...

Typo. Fixed.
ViperHills 7 Nov 2005 11:55
4/8
Also to be fair, a lot of the votes were probably cast before the news that Zelda's release had been put back. Then when people realised that it wasn't coming out for Christmas they had to vote for something else...like...the new Harry Potter game! Not exactly much more to choose from for exciting Christmas releases. Just the usual licence tat.
Greg2k 7 Nov 2005 12:39
5/8
I was once a supporter of game award ceremonies that would be similar to the Oscars. It's things like this that put me off the whole thing.
NiktheGreek 7 Nov 2005 12:57
6/8
Someone, please shoot the person who decided that "Best Film-Based Game" should even be a category. It's absolutely ridiculous. It promotes the mentality that gaming is merely a Hollywood merchandising branch, and until the industry stops thinking like this the perception will never change. Why aren't film-based games left to fight it out for individual system awards? Might it be that they don't stand a chance against the real gaming properties?

It speaks volumes that the game chosen wasn't based on a film at all. It says to me that film-based games in 2005 sucked, and that the people who choose the winners don't know the first thing about gaming.

If we're going to have an award where qualification is based purely on a game's brand name, let's shift the focus. Every single award winner this year bar one (Fahrenheit) relied on an established series in some capacity - the large majority as sequels, but there's also a remake of a sequel (Mario 64 DS) and a spin-off (World of Warcraft). So why not have a "Best Original Game" category? Oh, hang on, that encourages less milking of IP. Can't have that.

This isn't just a situation that exists with the Golden Joysticks, though. ITV's Gamestars awards show is crap. The BAFTAs are crap. In the US, Spike TV's Video Game Awards show is crap. The whole situation is completely s**t and a total waste of time, at present. What can we do about it? Not much, unfortunately.

Shoot the bloody lot of them, I say.
OptimusP 7 Nov 2005 18:30
7/8
Gameawards always have very strange and utter illogical outcome. Like those E3 awards for games who only were showed as a half minute long movie... and those awards are also voted by the press...

Best Xbox and PC game is strange since both came out like...in 2004! we're in 2005 last i checked.
Zelda is strange too...give that game that 2006 award then for bloody hell sake...
Super Mario 64 DS best handheld...hmmm... i have a copy of Advandce Wars that says otherwise and i think there are alot of people who have others in mind (Nintendogs comes to mind also)
To look for in Christmas...everybody forgot that Fire emblem is coming out for GameCube or something...more solid a game can't get, or how about ICO 2?
Nice to see that Fahrenheit gets a award though, seems like a very promising fresh approach of the adventure genre.

bottom line, gameawards always suck.
Cubeforever 8 Nov 2005 01:26
8/8
Best film based game- RESIDENT EVIL 4???????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Whata hell have those guys smoke?
Posting of new comments is now locked for this page.