Reviews// Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception

Posted 24 Oct 2011 17:00 by
Not only did they continue to follow him, but they continued to "Stay close" and to "Be careful". The game had wrested control from me for no apparent reason, and without giving me any notice or indication that it had done so. This was just confusing, and annoying.

The Clothes of the Emperor
The chaps at Naughty dog have told us that they are unable to make the graphical leap to the next level on PlayStation 3. And I can see what they mean. The game is as lovely looking as any PS3 game ever.

But this does not excuse their seeming inability to make the gameplay leap. Uncharted 3 simply fails to introduce anything worthwhile to surpass or even add to the previous games. More importantly, certain parts of the tinkering have not improved things. In fact, they have made them worse. But being worse than the PS3 exclusive high point that was Uncharted 2 leaves a lot of headroom, and I must say that Drake's Deception is far from a bad game. Very far indeed.

Multiplayer
The co-operative and competitive multiplayer features of the game that were introduced last time around return without any major modification. Though all of the DLC planned for post-release is aimed at the multiplayer game. With the single-player game coming in at around 11 hours if you do not bother to scour every level for treasure, the longevity in this game is in the multi-player aspects (previewed here by Mark).

Although Uncharted 3 was the largest ever multiplayer beta on PlayStation network, it still cannot compare with the popularity of multi-player games like CoD, but the Three Team Deathmatch, and the three player co-operative features make for a departure from the norm.

Third of Three
All in all, Uncharted 3 is an enjoyable game, with some major annoyances: as they did in the previous games, NPCs still block Drake's way when he is trying to get places. This can be particularly annoying when you are under fire, or against the clock. The QTE slugfests are simply dull, and the running out of the screen (towards the player) parts always piss me off.

However, on the ‘If it isn’t broken, why fix it?’ front, Uncharted 3 remains a thoroughly entertaining game. This time it falls short of the heights that Uncharted 2 achieved.

In any other franchise, Drake's Decption would be a high point… in the Uncharted series, however, it's a possible third of three. Quite simply, it lacks the novelty of the first game and the greatness of the second.

Conclusion
This is the same rip-roaring Boy’s Own adventure story-driven romp that the first two games were. It's just as beautiful, just as fun, just as immersive, just as cinematic. Precisely as beautiful. Exactly as fun. Precisely as immersive. Exactly as cinematic. It's a game trapped in amber.

It's a groundhog game. And for that, the law of diminishing returns applies. What was incredible last year is merely excellent this year. Had Naughty Dog managed to find any new twists, this game would have been another PS3 Killer App. As it is, if you have the other Uncharted games, you don't NEED this... but if you loved them, it's highly likely that you'll WANT it.

SPOnG Score: 89%
<< prev    1 2 -3-

Read More Like This


Comments

Really? 27 Oct 2011 23:49
1/8
This review is biased and inane.

You suck. Go play MW3 you f**k.
Really? 27 Oct 2011 23:56
2/8
Also, your link to Naughty Dog saying that the graphics don't represent a leap over Uncharted 2? You lied - and should be ashamed.

They say in their response to your question about graphics that EVERYTHING has been improved over Uncharted 2. Why lie in your review when anyone can simply click the link to the other article and see that you are blatantly lying?

Sponge has always been synonymous with inane and ignorant reporting - in some cases accusations of pay-offs and in other cases accusations of flat-out lying simply to acquire site hits.

F**k you and die.
more comments below our sponsor's message
TimSpong 28 Oct 2011 13:35
3/8
@Really?

Yup, what I said in the other thread that you decided to troll.
dyne 28 Oct 2011 21:27
4/8
Harsh words from Really. No need to stew in your own hatred for what I know to be a passionate site, first hand. I spent nearly five years there - they're not bad guys without moral gaming fibre. But they ARE critical, and so they should be. A review is a judgement afterall.

And let's be honest. How many reviews are truly unbiased? An RPG fan will likely review an RPG game - what do you think will happen? You could give this game to a fan of Dressage Simulator (it probably exists) and it would be impartial and objective. But at the same time, the words would be meaningless.

And the visuals? Sure it's the best-looking game on the system... but think back to the water-drenched brick walls of Shambala in its immediate predecessor. Is U3 really that much better?

I've spent nearly seven years continuing to read this site in the shadow of Wakefield House, and I stilll get a kick out of it. And as I prove by mashing away at the keyboard right now, sometimes I can't help but bite back. Maybe I'm biased too.

Out of curiosity Really - I assume you've completed the game yourself?

SPOnG - sometimes I miss you guys.
SamJM 1 Nov 2011 15:51
5/8
As much as I think I will disagree with these comments when I pick the game up tomorrow, I respect that this is indeed your opinion and it will more than likely differ from mine. Hence I think the people on here who are kicking up a fuss over the fact that you have some problems with the game need to grow up. If they don't like the review, don't follow it, make up your own god damn minds.
TheSonicMole 1 Nov 2011 16:03
6/8
@Really?

It's an opinion. The reviewer is free to have one that differs to your own.

And why so angry? Your underwear too tight today?
Tom 19 Nov 2011 16:15
7/8
The game is overrated.

I think 85% for the same game is far too much.

This is Uncharted 2.5 dosen't deserves more than 85% for me.
AmandaGames 10 Dec 2011 19:01
8/8
RRS187 is a Nazi moderator on the Reddead dot us website. This German bitch bans anyone with different views then he has or if they don't get along with his fellow cheaters corvettezr1-13 and cuban_gang_alex. The Reddead dot us website has become a safe haven for the biggest cheaters on Red Dead Redemption. Several people have complained about him but the site administrators have failed to act. This nazi bitch is also a cheater on Red Dead Redemption for the Platstation 3. He uses a modded PS3 console with an aimbot and a modified controller. This bitch needs to get a life and stop abusing what little power he has.
Posting of new comments is now locked for this page.