A real Elise takes its input from an (admittedly fairly highly-geared) steering column, but the car in the game takes it from a tiny joystick, with around 3cm of movement. So even though it is "analog", movements are massively amplified to the point of being near digital. If the game engine does not accommodate for this, that would explain the car's most un-Elise like handling.
Other cars handle better, but none of them handle well. This is supposition of course, but it would provide a logical explanation of WHY the car handling is like it is, even if not an excuse for why it's so dry and uninspiring to play.
GT5 serves up races roughly split into three categories, Arcade Mode, Specials and Racing Series. Arcade mode should, one suspects, provide a noticeably different driving experience to the racing modes, offering more point-and-shoot fun for casual driving game fans. And I am sure it does. I mean, I am certain it must. But to be honest, it's not exactly obvious.
Clearly, all of my bad feelings about
GT5 may just be down to them failing to include my car. 1,300 cars and they do not include the What Car Hot Hatch of the year, and generally best value
drivers' car on the road - the Renault Sport Megane 250. It was in
Forza 3, which came out before the car did. They have the Rover 25 GTi, and the Toyota Paseo but not RS250... says it all.
In Passing
In a "normal" world, a new
GT game would monopolise my time for month to come, but with so much of
Need for Speed Hot Pursuit left to play, I can't see myself going back to it after the review is written.
I don't like stating that
GT5 is a turkey. A little piece of my youth dies when I even think it. But anyone who does not admit it, anyone who fears for the pulled ads and refused review copies and dare not stand up and state openly that this game is a steaming bird needs to come here, and as I said, I will fist fight them to the death.
In conclusion
By Tim Smith
As I said, because we've only touched on both online and off here, I'm not giving the overall game a score. That'll happen later today. Right now it's 03:46am on Wednesday 24th November.
The feeling around the office is one of sad resignation. It's the same feeling that occurred after
Star Wars Episode I or Guns'n'Roses'
Chinese Democracy, but worse.
There are so many good ideas in
GT5. So many nods to what we wanted in damage, weather, car flipping,
Top Gear, karting, community, but like that market stall bag of goodies, none of them seems to work properly. As a whole it's a flat experience.
Right now, if I were to score the game, it would be a 03:47am score having played the game since Saturday and online only tonight.
Later today, more Online, more specials, more track building, more RPG team management... and a score. And I ask the question: "Why is the racing line indicator so 1999?"... by the way, I turned it off. Night all, or rather... good morning readers!