X-box fire terror

> Games Discussion > SPOnG Comments Index

Topic started: Wed, 23 Nov 2005 17:10Log-in or register to post to this topic.
Page:«12
sionevs
Joined 15 Nov 2005
20 comments
Wed, 23 Nov 2005 17:10
It was on the front page of my local paper yesterday (Daily post N.Wales) that an X-box had caught fire while a child was playing it, it burnt the house down to the floor. Luckily the child and asthmatic mother were pulled out by a passing nieghbour. Fire crews if this passing hero hadnt gone in, chanses r they wouldnt b here

This brings up serious saftey issues, as the mother had already complained to the microsoft hotline about a flickering image. After this news i would not buy the console for my children, as microsoft are reluctant to comment about the fire, and seem to be ignoring it.

I would like anyone who has had any problem with an X-box (or any other console) to drop me a line to see how safe we really are while playing the games we love
DoctorDee
Joined 3 Sep 1999
2130 comments
Wed, 23 Nov 2005 19:17
sionevs wrote:
This brings up serious saftey issues, as the mother had already complained to the microsoft hotline about a flickering image. After this news i would not buy the console for my children, as microsoft are reluctant to comment about the fire, and seem to be ignoring it.


Oh, c'mon, please. I'm not Microsoft's biggest fan. But be realistic. The Xbox is a piece of electrical equipment. It could have been mis-treated in any number of ways since these people bought it.

If the children playing it had been properly supervised, surely the fire would have been detected and extinguished before it became in inferno.

There may be blame to level in this instance, but with almost several million Xboxes sold, it's unlikely to be the Xbox that is the culprit.

And why would Microsoft's help line consider a "flickering picture" on a (probably) out of warranty Xbox something they should respond to?

If the parents thought the Xbox was faulty, they should have had it checked out before risking their kids life by using it as their babysitter.
Ditto
Joined 10 Jun 2004
1169 comments
Wed, 23 Nov 2005 21:18
DoctorDee wrote:

Oh, c'mon, please. I'm not Microsoft's biggest fan. But be realistic. The Xbox is a piece of electrical equipment. It could have been mis-treated in any number of ways since these people bought it.

If the children playing it had been properly supervised, surely the fire would have been detected and extinguished before it became in inferno.


But you've got admit, you hardly expect your game console to blow up.
miacid
Joined 18 Jan 2004
262 comments
Wed, 23 Nov 2005 21:47
I wonder if they had one of the power packs/cables that were recalled earlier this year!

I'm not defending Microsoft but it's also annoying when the press jump on a head line because it involves computer games.
config
Joined 3 Sep 1999
2088 comments
Thu, 24 Nov 2005 13:00
Adam M wrote:
DoctorDee wrote:

Oh, c'mon, please. I'm not Microsoft's biggest fan. But be realistic. The Xbox is a piece of electrical equipment. It could have been mis-treated in any number of ways since these people bought it.

If the children playing it had been properly supervised, surely the fire would have been detected and extinguished before it became in inferno.


But you've got admit, you hardly expect your game console to blow up.



Indeed. There strict regulations (BS, CE, UL, CA, VDE, etc) which, in order to pass, you must purposefully damage the equipent whilst it's draped in cheesecloth. If the cloth catches fire, it's a fail and back to the drawing board. I used to do this when working at an electronics equipment manufacturer. Flicking a switch to short out key components on a fully loaded 1kw power supply can give spectacular results - but rarely a fire.
sionevs
Joined 15 Nov 2005
20 comments
Sat, 26 Nov 2005 21:32
It doesnt really matter what the odds of the fire happening were. if it was 1 in 100 000 000, it means that there is a chance it could happen, and that your console could be the 1 faulty one. I accept that it is impossible to have a 0 fault record, but this was as close as close shaves get to a tragic loss.
sionevs
Joined 15 Nov 2005
20 comments
Sat, 26 Nov 2005 21:34
It doesnt really matter what the odds of the fire happening were. if it was 1 in 100 000 000, it means that there is a chance it could happen, and that your console could be the 1 faulty one. I accept that it is impossible to have a 0 fault record, but this was as close as close shaves get to a tragic loss.
DoctorDee
Joined 3 Sep 1999
2130 comments
Sun, 27 Nov 2005 12:12
sionevs wrote:
It doesnt really matter what the odds of the fire happening were. if it was 1 in 100 000 000, it means that there is a chance it could happen, and that your console could be the 1 faulty one. I accept that it is impossible to have a 0 fault record

That statement is directly contradictory. In one part of it you say that YOU ACCEPT that it is possible to get a zero fault record. In another part, you say that 1 in 100,000,000 is unacceptable.

What's your point, caller?
sionevs
Joined 15 Nov 2005
20 comments
Tue, 29 Nov 2005 17:03
I am tying to argue both sides of the argument as an impartial observer. This way we get the perspective of all the parties involved so we can make an accurate statement. It is foolish to choose a side without seeing the full picture. In essence i am trying to get arguments for both sides going. A debate if you would.
OptimusP
Joined 13 Apr 2005
1174 comments
Tue, 29 Nov 2005 18:42
There are people who use the Xbox360 powerblock as a central heating device it seems.
Going by all the complaints about overheating powerblocks i find it very easy to believe those people.
LUPOS
Joined 30 Sep 2004
1422 comments
Wed, 30 Nov 2005 15:22
i dont doubt those people... but there are also hundreds of thousands of people like me who... have good xboxs so they arent onlien complaining... my 360 and its power brick are sitting happily on my carpet completley error free.

although to be honest the thing did lock up on me twice while loading save games from condemened. but seeign as it was that game only i am inclined to believe it was a fault in the software. course i haven't played many other games in great length yet, i'll keep ya'll posted if i have the prob again.
_____
OptimusP
Joined 13 Apr 2005
1174 comments
Wed, 30 Nov 2005 18:39
The things why i said it is because there are literally complete forums with hunderds of people only talking how their Xbox360 crashed in 10-20 minutes. I find it a relief to read that not everyone has that, thank god.
Offcourse the people who buys those things on day one are offcourse people who are frequent gamers and 90% probably posts on forums on a regular basis. The internet does multiply the effect expotential by being the internet.

Question, how big is this powerbrick anyway? i heard in aspect of volume it's actually as big as a Revolution (three DVD cases stacked upon each other), thats BIG!
LUPOS
Joined 30 Sep 2004
1422 comments
Wed, 30 Nov 2005 19:53
its huge.... like... my forearm.... like.... the size of a standard power strip... but beefier... about 1/3 the size of the actual systemi would say... and it has a three prong plug on it... not the polarized one most consoles do but the full on heavy gauge power cable... like off a pc... although i dont know what the outlets over in euope land actualy look like.


its got vents and even a little light on it so you know its working.


volume wise it may be similar to a revo... but its shapped very dif... and the revo will most likely have an external brick liek the cube did anyway... course with the recent reports of it being not much better than a GC, especialy first round games, it will probably be much smaler
____
Ditto
Joined 10 Jun 2004
1169 comments
Wed, 30 Nov 2005 21:21
LUPOS wrote:
its got vents and even a little light on it so you know its working.


It's really Microsoft's spy station.

It videos and records everything you do in that room and sends it back to Microsoft using either the Xbox 360 or the mains power lines.
config
Joined 3 Sep 1999
2088 comments
Thu, 1 Dec 2005 14:00
LUPOS wrote:
and the revo will most likely have an external brick liek the cube did anyway... course with the recent reports of it being not much better than a GC, especialy first round games, it will probably be much smaler


Is anyone else a little baffled over the recent kerfuffle about the Revo's graphics being "not much better than the GC"? It's been all over Joysdique and other pop blogs like a nasty rash.

Do these flapping 'tards not recall Nintendo saying that it would not get draw into a graphical willy waving match with MS and Sony, and felt that it was more important to create better, more accessible game than to throw around a bazillion 16x AA polys?


<< Prev12

Log-in or register to permanently change your layout setting.