Daily Mail Gets Video Game Gullible - UPDATED

Quotes Prof who appears on website of brain training software company

Posted by Staff
Dr Susanne Jaeggi
Dr Susanne Jaeggi
If there's one thing worse than UK tabloid The Daily Mail attacking video games with no basis, it's UK tabloid The Daily Mail trying to support video gaming.

Today The Mail reports that, "Brain training computer games can improve children's grades within weeks, scientists have found."

"A study showed that video puzzles designed to exercise a child's 'working memory' boosted reasoning and problem solving skills for at least three months."

All very positive stuff. So, tell us about these 'scientists' and 'a study'.

"The new research, by psychologists at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor, tested the effects of brain training on 62 school children with an average age of eight and nine."

Brilliant.

So, what do the 'scientists' have to say on the matter. The DM quotes a single psychologist - called Dr Susanne Jaeggi, "who led the study": 'The current findings add to the literature demonstrating that brain training works, and that transfer effects may even persist over time.'

Excellent. What the paper forgets to mention, or more likely didn't research when it reprinted the press release was that Dr Jaeggi's professional standing and image are used by a company called IQMindware with the disclaimer at the bottom of the page on which these credentials (and those of other professionals) are is used that, "These individuals are not directly involved in the development of IQ Mindware™ software." That's our emphasis.

In fact, Dr Jaeggi has been in contact with SPOnG directly and would like to make it clear that, despite i3Mindware using her name and image on its credentials page:

"I would like to point out that I am NOT working with a company called IQMindware, nor do I endorse any of their programs or software. I do independent research and I am not charging my participants for doing the training."

Of course, we did not suggest that Dr Jaeggi charges participants in her research. In fact, we said this:

"Now, we're not saying that the research is flawed or not carried out with absolute, professional objectivity, we just thought we'd help the DM out with its games coverage."

We hope that clears things up, and that IQMindware clarifies that the Dr has no involvement in the development of its software.

So, to help out the DM, we'll tell you that IQMindware sells i3 Mindware software, for brain training. It'll cost you $44.99 for a single-user licence or $59.99 for a three-device licence on Mac and PC, as you can see here.

No need to thank us, DM. Well, there is, stop writing about games.

As a further update, Dr Jaeggi has responded to us following our recent update with some interesting information regarding the IQMindware company: "I was not aware that IQ Mindware was using my image, suggesting that I was working with them, and I asked them to take it down."

So, it appears that our little story has helped somewhere.

Sources:
The Daily Mail
IQMindware

Comments

Susanne Jaeggi 14 Jun 2011 13:47
1/3
Tim Smith, I am the researcher, Dr. Susanne Jaeggi you mention in your article above. I would like to point out that I am NOT working with a company called IQMindware, nor do I endorse any of their programs or software. I do independent research and I am not charging my participants for doing the training. Please remove this statement from your blog! Thank you. Susanne Jaeggi, PhD; The University of Michigan
TimSpong 14 Jun 2011 18:54
2/3
Dear Dr Jaeggi

Thank you for responding to the story with the clarification that I have added.

We were obviously lead to believe that you had some indirect involvement "in the development of IQ Mindware™ software" by dint of the company displaying the statement “Dr Susanne Jaeggi. University of Michigan. Lead the research project that demonstrated an intelligence gain from dual n-back training” alongside your image on its credentials page, with the disclaimer on that page, "these individuals are not directly involved in the development of IQ Mindware™ software." (My emphasis.)

I would like to make it clear that at no point in the story did we say that you are charging participants in your research. In fact, we made it very clear that we were not casting any aspersions on the research itself.

Please feel free to contact me directly if you have any further comments you feel you need to make: tim@spong.com

Regards

Tim Smith
Iain Lee 14 Jun 2011 22:17
3/3
Cool story bro
Posting of new comments is now locked for this page.