X05: J Allard interview

> Editorial Comments > SPOnG Comments Index

Topic started: Mon, 10 Oct 2005 18:36
Click here to view the editorial this topic refers to.
marmaduke
Joined 9 Nov 2004
36 comments
Mon, 10 Oct 2005 18:36
Now is this actually an interview by Spong's Daniel Boutros or is it by Eurogamer's Kristan Reed?

http://www.eurogamer.net/article.php?article_id=61217

Someone isn't crediting their articles properly. Own up now, who is it?
Sienar
Joined 1 Oct 2005
2 comments
Mon, 10 Oct 2005 20:49
Eurogamer: "Eurogamer: Has the launch proved harder than you expected?

J Allard: No, we knew it was going to be really really hard. It's a really hard problem, but, you know, we're stepping up. As Gerhard (Florin, EA Europe chief) said yesterday, it takes guts, but it's the right thing to do, and often the right thing to do takes guts, and some things complicate it. Will it go without a hitch? No. We'll have some logistics issues, it's going to be difficult. We're buying a lot of capacity on planes and on boats and we're going to be co-ordinating a lot. Do I think it'll go flawlessly? I don't, but I think it's the right thing to do, and I think we'll look back on it more convicted [sic] than ever that it was the right thing to do, and we're very committed to it. It's a lot of late nights for a lot of people, and a lot of hard work, and we're going to get some heat. It's never fun to work really really hard and then get heat from the media, from retailers, from the consumer because we didn't have enough of the things or because something wasn't quite as perfect as we’d like it to be in our execution, but the team signed up for it, because it's the right thing to do."

Spong: "Has the launch proved harder than you originally imagined?

J Allard: No, we knew it was going to be really, really hard. It's a really hard problem, but, you know, we're stepping up. As Gerhard (Florin, EA Europe chief) said yesterday, it takes guts, but it's the right thing to do, and often the right thing to do takes guts. Will it go without a hitch? No. We’ll have some logistics issues, it's going to be difficult. We're buying a lot of capacity on planes and on boats and we're going to be co-ordinating a lot. Do I think it'll go flawlessly? I don't, but I think it's the right thing to do, and I think we'll look back on it, more convinced than ever that it was the right thing to do, and we're very committed to it.

It's a lot of late nights for a lot of people, and a lot of hard work, and we're going to get some heat. It's never fun to work really, really hard and then get heat from the media, from retailers, from the consumer because we didn't have enough of the things or because something wasn't quite as perfect as we’d like it to be in our execution, but the team signed up for it, because it's the right thing to do. "

What spong said about the article "We sat down with J Allard at X05 and asked him a few questions. Here’s the complete UK interview transcribed in full; "

In actuallity, it was Kristen Reed of eurogamer, not Daniel Boutros who did the interview. All Boutros did is rearange Reed's article so it may not look like he plagerized it on frist inspection.

Because spong does things like this, they will continue to be considered a second rate gaming page and will never be able to get actual interviews with anyone important.
marmaduke
Joined 9 Nov 2004
36 comments
Mon, 10 Oct 2005 22:59
Christ, you sound like a) a massive Eurogamer fanboy and b) someone who knows what he's talking about. This might just be part of the Spong content delievery b******s. Alternatively, you might be right.

Official statement please, kids.
LUPOS
Joined 30 Sep 2004
1422 comments
Tue, 11 Oct 2005 00:11
it is very suspect... i havent the slightest either way... but i have my assumptions biased as they may be.

it should be considered however that mr allard speaks to tons of peopel on a daily basis and the number of questions one can ask about the forth comming system is also rather limited. plus the eery similarity in answers is not unreasonable since it was not exactly an exclsuive interview and im sure "j" as paroted (sp?) these same little musings and remarks to more people than i have hair folicls... none the less... official word would be nice.... guys?

______
TigerUppercut
Joined 28 Jun 2000
799 comments
Tue, 11 Oct 2005 09:36
Sienar wrote:

In actuallity, it was Kristen Reed of eurogamer, not Daniel Boutros who did the interview. All Boutros did is rearange Reed's article so it may not look like he plagerized it on frist inspection.

Because spong does things like this, they will continue to be considered a second rate gaming page and will never be able to get actual interviews with anyone important.


1. It was an panel of interviewees. There was someone there from the FT, someone there from the Independent too.

2. You might notice that our piece is twice as long as the Euorgamer piece. The rest of the interview they'll publish in a few days I guess. You cock. If you'd bothered to read the whole thing rather than the first paragraph...

Think I've made my point. As for interviews with anyone important... All of the following were 100% exclusive 1-to-1 interviews:

Shigeru Miyamoto

Saturu Iwata

Peter Molyneux

Peter Moore

J Allard

Etc, etc, etc...

Wow. Having a forum is brilliant.

You should go back to Eurogamer and re-read your half an interview. We'll be fine with the full transcript. While there, wonder who actually asked the questions that got published in the J Allard piece.

You should also avoid SPOnG for a blinding interview with an illusive development studio (Radiant SilverGun anyone) in the coming days...
DoctorDee
Joined 3 Sep 1999
2130 comments
Tue, 11 Oct 2005 09:52
Sienar wrote:
In actuallity, it was Kristen Reed of eurogamer, not Daniel Boutros who did the interview.


In actuality, you don't have a clue what you are talking about. If we are ripping them off, how do you explain that our interview is twice as long as theirs?

When they publish a second half that is the same as ours, will you go one their forums and accuse them of ripping us off? No - thought not.

You do not post anything constructive to our forums.
In fact, you have only posted twice, both times to pimp Eurogamer.


marmaduke
Joined 9 Nov 2004
36 comments
Tue, 11 Oct 2005 11:17
Well, glad that's sorted out.
DeepFraught
Joined 11 Jun 2004
16 comments
Tue, 11 Oct 2005 12:41
Sienar wrote:
Because spong does things like this, they will continue to be considered a second rate gaming page and will never be able to get actual interviews with anyone important.


You really have no idea how a panel interview work, do you? Stop making a fool of yourself. Either shut the f**k up or only post when you have something interesting and constructive to contribute.
SPInGSPOnG
Joined 24 Jan 2004
1149 comments
Tue, 11 Oct 2005 12:54
DeepFraught wrote:
Either shut the f**k up or only post when you have something interesting and constructive to contribute.

Or funny. We likes funny.

In the "ha-ha: belly-laugh way, not in the "sad and pathetic loser with no friends who just might turn up at work any day with an AK47 and put a hole in his supervisers head" sort of way that you're already posting.

DeepFraught
Joined 11 Jun 2004
16 comments
Tue, 11 Oct 2005 13:25
Rod Todd wrote:
DeepFraught wrote:
Either shut the f**k up or only post when you have something interesting and constructive to contribute.

Or funny. We likes funny.

In the "ha-ha: belly-laugh way, not in the "sad and pathetic loser with no friends who just might turn up at work any day with an AK47 and put a hole in his supervisers head" sort of way that you're already posting.

Funny is good. True. Park it under "interesting", would you?

SPInGSPOnG
Joined 24 Jan 2004
1149 comments
Tue, 11 Oct 2005 14:27
DeepFraught wrote:

Funny is good. True. Park it under "interesting", would you?

Now, I can see how I might have been misconstrued here. And if I have, it would be entirely my fault. And I apologise.

While I was quoting you, DeepFraugh, the "sad psycho" part was intended entirely and exclusively for Seinar.

I hope this was clear, but apologise again if it was not.

imnotregret
Joined 4 Apr 2005
27 comments
Thu, 13 Oct 2005 20:41
So i suppose you've been keeping an eye on that origenxbox360 site you guys told us about?
fluffstardx
Joined 20 May 2004
633 comments
Thu, 13 Oct 2005 22:59
I still think the bunnies are funny.

That's about it, really.

Log-in or register to permanently change your layout setting.