Video game forum >

News Commentary

Solvents, Knives Harmful as Video Games

Topic started: 11 May 2009 @ 12:07
Click here to view the news article this topic refers to.
This forum allows anonymous posting.

Click to post in this threadPost reply Click to search for messages in this or any other forumSearch Forums
Solvents, Knives Harmful as Video Games
Mon, May 11, 09 @ 12:07
Posted by Psalms
>>>Anonymously posted
I don't really understand you objection to this. Saying certain games are harmful to young minds (OK, maybe not lives) doesn't seem unreasonable. Does SPOnG let its 6 year old play GTA and The Guy Game?

I don't think that there was any suggestion that they were equivalent to knives, although its strange that music isn't mentioned. I also find it strange that there is no clear book classifications board, at least no one that I know of.


3 direct replies to this message.
Solvents, Knives Harmful as Video Games
Mon, May 11, 09 @ 12:24
Posted by haritori
Registered: 4 Jul 2007
Posts: 1659
Replying to Psalms [go]
in all fariness it did include DVD!!, although that in no way always them to state that games and DVD are as harmful as said Guns and Knives although i have heard New SUper mario bros thrown at a 45 degree angle towards the corner of a childs head can cause more damage than a .45 Magum.
Pround Owner of a 128k Spectrum


1 direct reply to this message.
Re: Solvents, Knives Harmful as Video Games
Mon, May 11, 09 @ 12:44
Posted by Tim Smith [mod]
Registered: 6 Nov 2006
Posts: 1364
Replying to haritori [go]
haritori wrote:
... i have heard New SUper mario bros thrown at a 45 degree angle towards the corner of a childs head can cause more damage than a .45 Magum.


Exactly... absolutely. And sniffing an Xbox 360 Elite will get you high enough to choke!

Cheers

Tim
Editorial Director - SPOnG.com
'Blame Me - tim@spong.com'


No replies to this message.
Solvents, Knives Harmful as Video Games
Mon, May 11, 09 @ 16:28
Posted by Joji
Registered: 12 Mar 2004
Posts: 3888
Replying to Psalms [go]
These snobby MPs don't surprise me anymore. They never do their research and just clutch at straws. Keith Vaz is enough of a display of that kind of thinking, yet they see fit to spend money the games industry brings into the country.

Think I'll go sell that used copy of American Psycho, to the kid next door.
"Plane!?....I Ain't Gettin On No Plane"


No replies to this message.
Re: Solvents, Knives Harmful as Video Games
Mon, May 11, 09 @ 18:02
Posted by Tim Smith [mod]
Registered: 6 Nov 2006
Posts: 1364
Replying to Psalms [go]
Psalms wrote:
I don't really understand you objection to this. Saying certain games are harmful to young minds (OK, maybe not lives) doesn't seem unreasonable. Does SPOnG let its 6 year old play GTA and The Guy Game?


One big objection is that you can walk into an A&E department, walk up to the nearest triage nurse and ask, "How many deaths or injuries can you say were caused by guns, knives, solvents or booze?" without being looked at as if you were mad. The same can't be said when asking the same question about video games.

Psalms wrote:
I don't think that there was any suggestion that they were equivalent to knives, although its strange that music isn't mentioned. I also find it strange that there is no clear book classifications board, at least no one that I know of.


Not a suggestion, a statement. And it's not strange that music wasn't mentioned... no matter how hard Tipper Gore tried, no one has yet been able to attribute a death to a book (not even Catcher in the Rye, Lennon fans), a piece of music (not even Helter Skelter, history fans) or a video game.

No, I am wrong! I apologise. There are one or two books that probably can be blamed for quite a few million deaths over the centuries... so if one was to introduce a rating system for ideas/books, I'd imagine that the 'Holy' ones should get the "Do not allow this near the mentally unstable, easily lead, gullible or manipulative" rating.


Cheers

Tim
Editorial Director - SPOnG.com
'Blame Me - tim@spong.com'


No replies to this message.


Log-in or register to permanently change your layout setting.

. . .