Video game forum >

News Commentary

Tougher Video Game Rating System Coming

Topic started: 8 Feb 2008 @ 12:51
Click here to view the news article this topic refers to.
This forum allows anonymous posting.

Click to post in this threadPost reply Click to search for messages in this or any other forumSearch Forums
Tougher Video Game Rating System Coming
Fri, Feb 8, 08 @ 12:51
Posted by irritant
Registered: 26 Mar 2007
Posts: 84
Simple solution for the industry: Don't use realistic graphics in any game that could be considered violent. Use cartoon-like GFX such as in Team Fortress 2 and the problem goes away.
Acorn Electron - 12" Ferguson B&W TV - Philips Cassette Deck ;-)


6 direct replies to this message.
Tougher Video Game Rating System Coming
Fri, Feb 8, 08 @ 13:41
Posted by James
>>>Anonymously posted
Replying to irritant [go]
:irritant?? are you being sarcastic, a cartoon GTA4, or a cartoon resident evil.

why not just make all horror and gangster films cartoons and ban them if they aren't cartoons, if your serious I suggest you go back to the daily mail forums.

Hopefully tanya won't go all self righteous and screw the videogames industry over by making it a scapegoat, if the UK is to become like germany with a ban on red blood and everything violoent then I predict a massive increase in importing and piracy, there is no way in hell i'm playing a watered down version of GTA4 or Resi 5.


1 direct reply to this message.
Re: Tougher Video Game Rating System Coming
Fri, Feb 8, 08 @ 14:54
Posted by tyrion [mod]
Registered: 14 Oct 1999
Posts: 1703
Replying to James [go]
James wrote:
Hopefully tanya won't go all self righteous and screw the videogames industry over by making it a scapegoat

It doesn't matter what the Byron report says or recommends, the government can bend the words to fit the pre-decided policy it wants to pursue.

One piece of supporting evidence that is dismissed in the summary can be leaked to the press and they can be expected to splash it all over the front pages, ignoring the conclusions of the report completely. Then the government releases a quiet disapproval statement that the findings are being ignored by the press, waits for the public outcry from Middle England and then cracks down on games because of the "concerns of the public".

And all the way through it, the government is seen as even-handed because it commissioned a report that was lauded by the trade body of the games industry.
Tyrion
SPOnG.com
"I reject your reality and substitute my own."


No replies to this message.
Tougher Video Game Rating System Coming?
Fri, Feb 8, 08 @ 15:19
Posted by settingsun
>>>Anonymously posted
Replying to irritant [go]
So who thinks we arent going to see gta 4 released in the uk??? do you think his is going to lead to a ban on anything with the slightest violence?? if it does my 360 will not been seeing much action in the future as all well get is sports racing and kids games


No replies to this message.
Re: Tougher Video Game Rating System Coming
Fri, Feb 8, 08 @ 15:44
Posted by Tim Smith [mod]
Registered: 6 Nov 2006
Posts: 1363
Replying to irritant [go]
irritant wrote:
Simple solution for the industry: Don't use realistic graphics in any game that could be considered violent. Use cartoon-like GFX such as in Team Fortress 2 and the problem goes away.


If the recent advice from Mr Justice Mitting on the question of 'harm' is anything to go by, rendering all characters as stick figures with puppy faces won't be enough (scary image actually). It's the likelihood of 'potential harm' caused by playing this sick filth that's in question.

Also, cartoons get rated as well - see Crying Freeman from 1997(!) and its 18 rating.

Cheers

Tim
Editorial Director - SPOnG.com
'Blame Me - tim@spong.com'


No replies to this message.
1 2 3 > >>


Log-in or register to permanently change your layout setting.

. . .